Telly Thursday: Older Woman, GSOH, Seeks Decent Script.
March 11th, 2010
posted by Padraig Moran
YAY! It’s a new series of Friends! And look, Monica’s moved somewhere sunny. She looks great. I wonder where Chandler and the rest are… Oh they’re divorced? Hang on, why’s it called Cougar Town?
Yup, the hopes and dreams of Friends fans everywhere are to be dashed against the rocks of RTE2 this Tuesday, for it’s not actually a new series of Friends, just a new series where Courtney Cox inexplicably puts her Monica hat back on, despite the fact that this is an entirely different character in an entirely different show. She’s not the only one though, in fact for the first few episodes of new comedy Cougar Town, it feels like this is where old sitcom stars go to die. Christa Miller is virtually a carbon copy of her character Jordan from Scrubs, while Busy Phillips reprises the role she’s been playing for a good ten years now, i.e. that of a whorish Barbie doll who’s been left out in the sun too long.
Coming to us from ABC, Cougar Town takes us into the world of Jules Cobb, a forty-year-old divorcee who’s venturing back out into the world of datin’ and relatin’. She’s flanked by two best friends who hate each other (Miller and Phillips), a dead-beat ex-husband and a perpetually mortified 18-year-old son. Add to this mix her rather winsome neighbour Josh Hopkins (who plays her rather obvious and conveniently just-divorced-as-well love interest), and there’s a recipe here for a slick and sexy series, that could be executed with incredible panache. Like a female dominated version of Nip/Tuck perhaps, where Mrs. Robinson skips the surgery and has the surgeon instead.
Unfortunately though, the first couple of episodes fall horrendously flat. Aside from the séance for dead sitcom characters, the script itself is insultingly stupid, with paper thin plotting that leaves the show feeling like a random assortment of characters with hit-and-miss one liners. If it were funny, this would hardly matter, and rarely does in the better sitcoms, but at times it reads like a transcript of Loose Women, performed by a bunch of beaming Saturday Night Live rejects. It does get a bit better as the series progresses, but takes nearly nine episodes to muster up any kind of heart or humour. This is slow progress even by rookie standards, but when your creators and writers are Scrubs, Friends and South Park alumni, what excuse can there really be?
The sad fact may be that Cougar Town is just another casualty of ABCs reputation for taking great ideas and mismanaging them to the point of abuse. Just look at Flash Forward, a wonderful idea and opportunity that once committed to film became little more than a exercise in keeping Joseph Fiennes out of trouble. Or Desperate Housewives and Ugly Betty. Both had a candy-coloured promise to begin with, and indeed enjoyed great first seasons. But by the time Mary Ellis is corpse-monologuing about the 19th consecutive murderer to move in across the street, you can’t help feeling the writers are like helpless bunnies caught in the headlights of their own success. Poor, dear Betty has met a similar fate, never matching the buzz of her initial storylines, and limping, as we speak, to her finale next month as a result.
Cougar Town seems to fit the pattern sadly, for even when it improves it’s at the cost of its core concept. Which is a shame, primarily because there aren’t many decent roles for older women, certainly not in sitcom land. Cougar Town could have been an empowering little treat that made you laugh and made your spinster aunt feel like maybe a night out in Coppers wasn’t such a bad idea after all, but it seems to be selling out without a dirty, cross-generational weekend in sight.
Unlike her hilarious foil Barb, whose lecherous slapstick is fatally underused, our heroine Jules isn’t long out of the gate before she’s being reined back in by forty something year old men her own age. In fact she doesn’t seem fit for this cougar lark at all, only boffing two young men within the first half of the series, and even then sticking to a ten-date rule that keeps her sheets tediously clean. These young men, as an aside, are some of the most perfunctorily drawn characters I’ve ever seen on TV, recurring in several episodes each but only blessed with only enough depth to facilitate the erections that seem to be their primary function. By nature of their pointlessness alone,the viewer can be in little doubt as to whose middle-aged arms Jules will be falling into.
The problem with Cougar Town, perhaps, is that it’s very, very safe. Cox is as squeaky clean as the surfaces her old incarnation Monica used to obsess over, and destined from the start to have a brief rush of freedom before quietly acquiescing to marriage and insemination by her all-American neighbour. The show will keep running through their romance, no doubt, but by then the whole thing will have beiged into the landscape of rom-sitcom tomfoolery. By contrast, shows like Fat Actress, and The Comeback were unapologetic in their middle-aged hellcat ethos, and suffered network censure as a result. With Cougar Town losing sight of its own ideals and edgy potential in the first few episodes, it may perversely do a bit better. Though if you were looking for a sassy and empowering portrayal of mature women who want to enjoy life and sod the social stigma, you’ll be better off watching Judge Judy.
Cougar Town premieres on RTE2 next Tuesday at 9.















